
Critical thinking seems to be a dying art. I say art because it is a learned process. We are not born critical thinkers. In fact, from my experience, most never attain the skill. And it is a skill. With that, most people mistake having an opinion for having a thought. An opinion is a reaction while critical thinking is a calculation.
So what, exactly, is critical thinking?
Here is what the dictionary says.
What is critical thinking according to the Dictionary?
Oxford Dictionary: noun; the objective analysis and evaluation of an issue in order to form a judgment.
Well, that’s clear. Here is my issue with this definition. Just because you “form a judgment” doesn’t mean it’s a good judgment, and that is where the critical part comes in.
What does AI say?
…the intellectually disciplined process of actively analyzing, evaluating, and synthesizing information to form a reasoned judgment.
Well, that’s better. At least it gets to analyzing and evaluating. But there is more.
What does Larry say?
Larry’s definition: the ability to think through an issue, see the obstacles, consider outcomes, and most importantly, to see the “law of unintended consequences” and how to avoid them.
If we do ‘this idea’, what could be the many results. Are the many results the outcome we are looking for? If not, what do we do to mitigate the bad. Maybe the original idea is bad and should be scrapped. The last part is sadly missing in today’s society. Unintended consequences are rampant in our day to day lives, and we pay the price.
Statements are made, laws are passed and not a single person seems to consider the “what ifs” that follow.
Linear Thinking vs. Systems Thinking
Our government is the worst offender and they make an easy target. A linear thinker sees a problem and applies a direct solution. “We need to save water”, and jumps to a quick, “let’s pass a law restricting shower heads.” They never get to System thinking. “If you restrict the shower heads, people will shower longer and use the same, or more water” That shows a lack of critical thinking.
The Government passes hundreds of laws, never once asking what it could lead to once passed.
Lets look at just a few examples:
- outlawing incandescent light bulbs with the only option, CFL bulbs which were dangerous and poisonous.
- outlawing decent shower heads, so the 30% reduction in flow required a 50% increase in shower time
- The Biofuel Mandates: They pushed corn-based ethanol to reduce oil independence, only to reduce the amount available for food. The global effect was to drive up food prices.
- Rent Controls: Which did the opposite by creating housing shortages and discouraging building maintenance. This is probably one of the worst examples that was supposed to help the poor but did not.
- Banning Plastic bags/straws: Need I say anything more.
- Encouraging manufacturers to move overseas because we were considered a “nation of ideas, not labor.” We are now paying for the ‘what if’ on this one.
- then the opposite, refusing to eliminate Daylight Saving Time even though 72% of their bosses (us) want it gone.
However, critical thinking is not just for distant elected and non-elected officials. It is also important in our personal lives.
Critical Thinking in Our Personal Lives
Recently, I was tasked with a simple project for an organization. It was so simple, it should only take one short afternoon to complete. Then I began laying out a plan sketch and realized one piece wouldn’t work. I had to re-think the whole project. Then the next design had a simple flaw toward the end. It wouldn’t work either.
This simple, short project ended up taking several weeks to work through to determine a design that would eliminate the problems. Then it only took a few hours to complete because there were no issues in the build.
I’d like to say that is the only project where this has happened but it is not. How many times have you gotten deep into a project and “discovered” it couldn’t be completed as originally thought?
That is what I’m talking about. Determining the problems before beginning.
Application of Critical Thinking
The next time you are tasked with a decision, take the time to think “through” the issue before jumping at the first idea you have. What are the negatives that could result?
Ask yourself: if this plan works perfectly, what else will break? Don’t just look for a judgment–form a calculation. It is the only way to stay ahead of the consequences.
It’s Important!

